Saving the Palestinian economy
Massachusetts - The expected formation of a new Palestinian cabinet based on
the Saudi-brokered power-sharing deal reached in Mecca between Hamas and
Fatah in February may finally bring an end to Palestinian bitter political
divisions and internecine violence that followed last year's stunning
electoral rise of Hamas to power. It may also herald the beginning of a
process that could potentially lead to a reversal of the year-long Israeli
and Western economic and diplomatic boycott which have proven to be very
costly for the Palestinians.
Such an outcome would certainly be a major break for the 4 million residents
of the West Bank and Gaza who have over the past year been devastated by
continued lack of life's basic needs and an unprecedented rise in the level
of internal lawlessness and anarchy.
A more serious question, however, is whether a future Palestinian unity
government that, at best of circumstances, would be operating under
conditions similar to those existing on the eve of the January 2006
elections could, among other things, be able to revive the moribund
Palestinian economy and effectively addresses the chronic problems of
poverty and unemployment currently plaguing the Palestinian territories. On
that front, there are grounds for doubt.
Under continued crisis conditions, dating back since the outbreak of the
second intifada in September 2000, extensive damage has been done to the
Palestinian economic structure to the point where a mere return to a
pre-2006 state of affairs may no longer be sufficient to jump-start the
deeply stagnant domestic economy. Two signs in particular are very
disturbing in this regard, both for their adverse impact on the long-term
stability of the Palestinian land, and, by extension, the stability of a
region that already has more than its share of trouble.
First, there is the recent warning by the World Bank regarding the eroding
capacity of the Palestinian economy to generate fast growth rates even under
a less oppressive Israeli closure regime - a regime that has long been
identified as the single most significant factor hindering Palestinian
Second, there is the continued reporting by the International Monetary Fund
on the increasingly unsustainable fiscal position of the Palestinian
Authority even with the resumption of tax money transfers currently withheld
by Israel - a situation that will ultimately call for harsh fiscal
adjustment measures that, if implemented under pre-2006-like conditions,
could risk igniting further political and social unrest.
Under such circumstances, and absent any significant change in the highly
constrained operating environment in the Palestinian areas, a resumption of
foreign aid alone, important as it may be for mitigating Palestinian
mounting suffering, is not sufficient to arrest a further deterioration in
economic conditions, or to prevent a potentially more pernicious recurrence
of the crisis.
We already know this from past experience. Under continued conflict
conditions that have prevailed since September 2000, and despite the
doubling of foreign aid to an average of $1 billion annually between 2001
and 2005, the Palestinian economy was worse off on the eve of January 2006
elections than it was in 2000, with poverty, unemployment and personal
income levels all registering constant deterioration.
With such a dismal performance record, returning back to pre-2006 conditions
is not an economically viable option. That road, for all practical purposes,
has already reached a dead-end.
What is now needed is a holistic approach to the Palestinian socioeconomic
plight: one that views the current economic freefall in the Palestinian
areas not merely as a post-Hamas phenomenon that can be dealt with either by
ousting Hamas or changing it, but as an integral part of how things have
developed in the West Bank and Gaza over the past dozen years.
The first step on such a new course, if it is destined to be followed, must
be the realization by all parties, including the Palestinian side, of the
high long-term cost of returning back to a nonviable "old" status quo, and
the virtual impossibility of achieving any sort of economic recovery under
continued conflict conditions. Once this crucial step is taken, then it
becomes possible to design and implement a comprehensive package that should
eventually provide the Palestinian economy with what has so far been grossly
lacking for a sustained U-turn to recovery and growth to take hold: an
adequate control over physical resources, effective policy tools for
economic management and modern institutions to support the attainment of
high growth rates.
Only in such a different environment will it become possible for the
relatively small Palestinian economy to take advantage of some of its hidden
- and so far largely under utilized - strengths: its human capital, its
entrepreneurial capabilities, its rich diaspora, its proximity to the more
advanced Israeli economy, its close ties with the neighbouring Arab
economies and a world that has always shown a readiness to be a partner in
For that possibility to be translated into reality, however, and for
Palestine to be able to aim for a new "economic horizon," the root political
causes of the current socioeconomic crisis in the West Bank and Gaza need to
be tackled first, and fast. Absent any positive and serious noise on that
front, we are likely to continue down the same slippery road: unable, or
perhaps unwilling, to see the glaringly alarming signs along the way,
heading yet again toward another costly dead-end.
Dr Mohammed Samhouri is a senior fellow at the Crown Center for Middle East
Studies at Brandeis University. This article is based on a much elaborated
study by the author titled “Looking Beyond the Numbers: The Palestinian
Socioeconomic Crisis of 2006” published in February 2007.
Source: Arabic Media Internet Network, 5 March 2007,
Is the tide
A Jordan Times Editorial says following the Iraq Tragedy
serious and constructive diplomacy needed...
Rabbi Michael Melchior from Jerusalem to the heart of Hebron:
Islam of a different kind
I went to Hebron to express condolences to the family of the
Hebron sheik, Talal Sider, who in the past few years was a senior and full
partner to the attempts to persuade the leaders of the three faiths to turn
religion into a lever for peace, brotherhood and hope...
investigate opportunities, too?
A huge number of commissions of inquiry has been established.
Clearly the crowded line-up is a humiliating reminder of how far this
country has slipped into disarray...
Gespräche zwischen Jerusalem und Riad:
Accept the Saudi Initiative
Four years after it was first presented, the Arab Peace
Initiative is finally coming to centre stage...